The Agent Who Sat on the Other Side of the Desk
Tricia Baratta spent 17 years as a workers' comp claims specialist at Travelers Insurance — and now uses that insider knowledge exclusively to protect New York businesses and homeowners.
From the Insurance Company's Side — to Yours
Before becoming an independent agent, Tricia spent over 17 years at Travelers Insurance as a workers' compensation claims specialist. She sat on the other side of the desk — the insurance company's side — conducting the very audits that determine how much New York businesses pay in workers' comp premiums every year.
That background is rare. Most insurance agents sell policies. Tricia understands how those policies are enforced, where the rules get complicated, and exactly where businesses get overcharged when they don't have someone in their corner who knows the system inside out.
Today, she uses that knowledge exclusively for her clients. When a workers' comp audit arrives, she reviews it line by line. When a Long Island homeowner needs flood coverage that will actually hold up after a storm, she knows which policies are solid and which fall short.
Comp Matters Inc. is located at 12 Oak Street, Bayport, NY 11705, serving Nassau County, Suffolk County, and communities across Long Island's South Shore.
Tricia Baratta — Founder, Comp Matters Inc.
Independent Insurance Agent, Bayport, NY
Why New York Trusts Comp Matters
Thirty years of insurance experience — including 17 years inside one of the country's largest carriers — on your side.
Insider Audit Knowledge
Tricia knows exactly how workers' comp auditors think, because she was one for 17 years. She reviews policies, challenges classifications, and guides clients through audits so they pay what is fair — and not a dollar more.
Long Island Local
Based in Bayport, NY. Tricia lives and works on Long Island and knows its carriers, flood zones, and coastal risks better than anyone. Nassau County, Suffolk County, South Shore — she knows the market deeply.
Free Policy Reviews
Most clients who come in for a review discover they are overpaying or underinsured. A free review takes under an hour and could save you thousands. No pressure, no obligation — just an honest look at your coverage.
Independent Agent
Not tied to any single carrier. Tricia shops multiple companies to find the best coverage at the best price — then stays with you through audits, claims, and renewals. Your agent, not the insurance company's.
Coverage for New York Businesses & Homeowners
All lines of insurance through one trusted New York agent.
Workers Comp
Audit representation & policy reviews for NY businesses
Homeowners Insurance
Coverage for New York & South Shore properties
Flood Insurance
NFIP & private flood coverage for Nassau & Suffolk County
Auto Insurance
Personal & commercial auto coverage in New York
Commercial Insurance
Business policies for New York companies
Life Insurance
Protect your family's financial future
Ready for an Honest Policy Review?
Call Tricia directly or send a message. Most clients find at least one area where they are overpaying or underprotected — and it costs nothing to find out.